Are villains supposed to be disliked?

Negan.

For any follower of The Walking Dead, the name ‘Negan’ immediately elicits intense reaction. This is the new baddie who ruthlessly bashed in the skulls of two beloved members of the group. This is the villain that’s completely broken the fearless Rick Grimes, making him kneel, weep, and beg. This is the diabolical dictator who gets whatever he wants by ruling with terror.

He is the new alpha dog in the world, and he is one mean brute.

Yet, despite all of this, when I join my companions every Sunday night to tune in to the next episode of The Walking Dead, we all hope that Negan shows up. We are disappointed when he doesn’t appear on screen, even thought that’s better for the main group of the show. We spend the entire week leading up to the next episode quoting Negan over and over again, mimicking his body language and voice. We find ourselves talking about how awesome Negan is, despite how much we hate him for subjugating our heroes.

Frankly, we love Negan.

It’s a strange feeling to love a villain. Normally, many shows and movies make it very clear to the audience who they are supposed to love and treat as the hero, and who they are supposed to despise and root against as the villain. While there is no doubt in any viewer’s mind that Negan is the villain, complete and utter hatred for him is difficult, and that is certainly done on purpose.

The fact that I have such mixed feelings about Negan is what makes The Walking Dead so beautiful at storytelling. Negan is the leader of his own group, a group that he is trying to keep alive. He is not insane; there is a reason for why he acts the way he does, a reason that makes sense to him. He has a backstory, a path that has lead him to where he is today. As the creator of the series Robert Kirkman even says, Negan is “the hero of his own story.”

As a viewer, I am forced to consider these questions of how bad Negan really is. He truly is the hero of his own story; from his point of view, Rick and his group unnecessarily ambushed and killed dozens of Negan’s men. Negan is just trying to keep his own group safe and alive, and for the sheer number of people that Rick and his gang slaughtered, for Negan to kill only two individuals does seem mighty merciful (from a certain perspective). Negan is a smart leader, who gets things done. He’s charming, he’s efficient, and he’s powerful. At what point, then, is he really villain, and not just another survivor who’s figured out a way to make it in the new world, no different than the protagonists of the show?

Advertisements

One thought on “Are villains supposed to be disliked?

  1. Colson says:

    I’ve always loved a good villain. Many of my favorites do indeed follow the popular idiom that leapt to mind even before I saw you mention it here. “Everyone is the hero of their own story.” Whether that is true or not, it does seem to be the crux of many a great antagonist. There is a certain dark charm that comes about when a work of fiction acknowledges that sometimes the road to hell is indeed paved with good intentions. Everyone agrees that they should do the right thing, but no one seems to agree on what that “right thing” is. Going forward, I’d suggest trying to capture some of the aspects of Negan that you find so riveting and pull them out when you find yourself in need of a good antagonist for a story. Complex villains are, almost without exception, very fun to write.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s